Summer Camino – day 10 > excerpt 3 (history)

Talking about wellbeing of one’s soul and manipulation by the Catholic Church brings me to the religious movement of the Cathars – Katharos in Greek meaning ‘pure’. Their history can shine more light onto religious events and circumstances between the 12th to 14th centuries ‒ the time when the Camino was probably in its heydays. The Cathars were a staunchly religious sect that believed in Jesus Christ and his gospel as related by the apostles. However, they also had knowledge of and probably access to some Gnostic writings, which portray a different picture of the events leading to the establishment of Christianity, often contrasting to what was prescribed by the Catholic Church. These differences had great relevance for the Cathars who did not agree with numerous practices of the Catholic Church or with its interpretation of the Bible.

The Cathars, for instance, did not believe in baptism, claiming that water was material and corruptible and could not sanctify the soul. They regarded any confession made to a priest as useless, as sins should and could not be forgiven so easily, and certainly not by mortal priests. They also disagreed with the adoration and veneration of the crucified Christ and the many relics that were idolised. They were opposed to the sacrament of the Eucharist (the Last Supper) as this was a gesture without relevance. They were convinced that the church had betrayed the true essence of the Christian faith and that the original purity of the message of Christ had been manipulated.

The Cathars also maintained that the Roman Catholic Church was morally, spiritually and politically corrupt. They had a very different understanding of how religion and church practice should be structured and did not believe that the Pope was the representative of God. They condemned the abuse of power the church claimed and demonstrated, which competed with kings and emperors in ecclesiastical as well as secular matters in those days. They also criticised the way the church, through fear and anxiety, controlled its followers with their doomsday and afterlife in hell predictions. Most of all the Cathars could not agree with the way wealth was accumulated and displayed.

In contrast to the Catholic way of life, the Cathar leaders, the Perfecti, lived a simple life and were dedicated to their flock. Not only did they surrender their worldly possessions to the community and live like true monks, they were also devoted to charity work, purity, prayer, preaching and tending to the sick. The Perfecti taught their followers to live a simple but pure life, a life of respect, gratitude, honesty and adherence to the Ten Commandments.

The Cathars also believed that the world was so evil that it could not have been created by a loving God. They alleged that it was created by an evil spirit that had been expelled from the perfection of heaven. Alternatively, they maintained that certain angelic souls embraced materialistic values and were reincarnated to earth where they adopted lifestyles of greed, deception and brutality, as demonstrated by many, even in ecclesiastic orders.

They furthermore believed in two external powers: these were Rex Mundi on one hand, ‘the devil and king of the underworld’ who created material desires, and the good and loving God who created order and peace and was the guardian of our spirit and of our souls in heaven. The aim of the Cathars was to reunite with the good and loving God, and to ultimately leave behind this material world; in their view the power-seeking Catholic Orders were corrupted by the pursuit of earthly power and success – they were no doubt greatly influenced by Rex Mundi.

According to their conviction, we are on this earth to transform our worldly existence into a realm of love, a state which we would approach as our souls became more pure. They believed in reincarnation to achieve this, accepting that many lifetimes were necessary to reach this goal.

The Cathars’ organisation grew into a popular mass movement which spread to many parts of Europe. Their strongholds in the south of France were Pau, Toulouse, Carcassonne and Montpellier, to name but a few. Here the resident nobles also feared the ever-increasing power of the Catholic Church and this led them to support and protect the Cathars in their fortified cities.

The Papacy perceived the movement as a threat to its religious supremacy and in 1176 the Cathars’ doctrine was declared heretical. The St Dominican Order was established in Languedoc to counter Cathar influences, but they had little success and in 1204 the Pope excommunicated Cathar sympathizing nobles, one of them being Raymond VI of Toulouse, who was not willing to support the Catholic Church any longer.

Pope Innocent III called on the French King Phillip II to lead a crusade against Cathar strongholds; Phillip declined. Pope Innocent then devised an idea which could have only been inspired by Rex Mundi and which demonstrates the secular powers he claimed for himself. He declared a crusade against the Cathars and their sympathisers and offered the land of the ‘heretics’ and their supporters to whoever would fight and overthrow them – an offer that many nobles from the north of France could not resist. And so the crusades against the Cathars and their allies in Languedoc, which at the time was a separately governed region before it became part of France at a later stage, started in 1209 and lasted for some twenty years.

Before the suppression of the Cathars the areas of Languedoc, Roussillon and Midi Pyrenees were prosperous agricultural districts with the highest population density in Europe. The region was governed by the County of Toulouse and other nobles, and cooperation amongst them was amicable: hardly any skirmishes are recorded for this period, which was unusual for that epoch.

The brutal, cruel and destabilizing crusades changed all this. Cistercian monk Arnaud Amalric was the legate and inquisitor sent by Pope Innocent III to attempt the re-conversion of the Cathars. He took his assignment very seriously and was zealous in his pursuit of the victims. He authorized torture, maiming and killing with great vigour until he died in 1225. The first city to be ransacked by the crusading armies was Beziers, in 1209. Catholics were asked to leave the city and the Cathars to surrender; however, both refused. The city was then stormed, the entire population of about 20 000 was massacred and the city burnt to the ground.

A Cistercian writer and community leader at the time recorded that, when Legate Arnaud was asked how he could distinguish between Cathars and orthodox Christians, his reply was “Kill them all, for the Lord knoweth them that are His!” This shows the Catholic sentiments at the time.

Dominance during the ensuing wars changed repeatedly. Initially the crusaders had the upper hand, but then the noble Cathar sympathisers prevailed. In 1223 King Phillip II of France died and his son and successor, King Louis VIII decided to join the Crusade. He won many skirmishes against Cathar sympathisers and the Cathar friends were hard pressed.

His reign only lasted for three years and when King Louis IX succeeded, he was still a child. His mother, the Queen Regent Blanche, who reigned on his behalf, also supported the French nobles and the crusade, and when with her help Toulouse fell in 1228, she offered Count Raymond of Toulouse, the son of Raymond VI who had always resisted the French forces, a treaty. She would allow him to remain ruler of Toulouse providing he denounced the Cathars and married his daughter off to King Louis’ brother. In this manner, through inheritance, Toulouse would eventually become French territory.

Raymond finally agreed and signed the treaty in 1229 – after which he was whipped and imprisoned. With the most powerful protector of the Cathars isolated, resistance diminished and the Crusade neared its end.

The last stronghold of the Cathars was Montsegur, a castle not far from Carcassonne, where their accumulated belongings were kept. The castle was perched high up on a steep, rocky mountain and in 1244, after a siege that lasted nine months, it was finally conquered by the crusaders. About 200 Perfecti were captured and burnt to death in an enormous bonfire in the valley below. There is a legend that some Perfecti escaped and returned later to retrieve the Cathar treasures hidden in the countryside – treasure that has never been found. Today this once proud castle is in ruins.

As a result of the Crusades the French Crown and its nobles annexed the separate and free southern regions of Languedoc, also known as Ossitania where the Ossitan language was spoken at the time. After the annexation to northern France, the French language, as it is still spoken today, prevailed. The Catalan dialect, as it is spoken in the adjacent Catalan Province in Spain, is similar to Ossitan, which, way back, was also called Lenga d’óc. Both languages experience a revival these days and so does the Languedoc spirit.

Pope Gregory IX wanted to eliminate the last remaining Cathars who had escaped capture, reconversion or death during the Crusades. He instructed the Order of the Dominicans in 1229 to establish an Inquisition, which only ended in 1310 – an astonishing 101 years after the outbreak of the crusade. It was the first Inquisition ever organised by the Catholic Church on this large scale.

The next major Inquisition took place in the 15th century and forced Jews and Muslims in Spain to convert to Christianity, maintain Catholic orthodoxy or leave the Iberian Peninsula. The harsh and inhumane proceedings of the inquisition with its cruel and unpredictable culture of denunciation promoted by the authorities to prevent persecution and torture of those involved, were diligently recorded in volumes which are still accessible today. It is fear under these circumstances that converts us to be cruel to our neighbours; similar behaviour was displayed under the Nazi period in Germany. Many other cultures in history and even many people today are tortured, but none suffered more cruelty than those manipulated during religious inquisitions with their related fanatic rhetoric. Actually, religious torture and manipulation is still widespread, even in these days, and I for one am frightened of this and any form of radicalism.

In later years the Cathars, frequently as a result of the Crusades and the Inquisition, reconverted to the Roman Catholic Church. They were often instructed, as a sign of penance, to embark on the pilgrimage to Santiago, and the Compostela letter became the proof for the authorities back home that they had completed the task.

Posted in Blog, Summer Walk permalink

About Dieter Daehnke

Born in 1941 in Gdansk, Poland. In March 1945 the family fled the Russian army. Met my wife Uta in Hamburg and as she is South African, I followed her home. We live in Cape Town, have 3 children, and 2 wonderful grandchildren. I established an Engineering company and since its sale, I enjoy walking Caminos. I have recently completed my book 'Journey of a Stickman'.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


× nine = 36